Every item we sell is inspected and given one grade from the scale below before it's listed. The grade is in the listing description, and the photos show every flaw we mention. It's the same scale on our eBay store and here.
The four grades
Mint (M)
Flawless. If sealed, factory-sealed and never opened with perfect packaging. If opened/displayed, no detectable flaws — no paint chips, scratches, fading, or wear; all parts present and intact; original box/packaging (if applicable) present and clean.
Near Mint (NM)
Excellent with only the most minor flaws visible on close inspection — faint handling marks or very light shelf wear. Complete and displays beautifully. Packaging, if present, may show only very minor shelf wear.
Good (G)
Solid display piece with normal wear consistent with age and handling — light scratches, minor paint nicks, or slight fading. Complete and structurally sound. Packaging, if present, may show creases, edge wear, or yellowing.
Fair (F)
Noticeable wear or flaws — visible paint loss, scratches, fading, oxidation, or a minor missing/damaged part. Still displayable, or a good candidate for restoration or parts. All known flaws fully disclosed.
What every listing tells you
- Complete or not. Mint and Near Mint items are always complete. If anything is missing (a base, mounting screws, an accessory, paperwork the item normally ships with), the listing says so, whatever the grade.
- Flaws, in plain words. Paint chips, scratches, fading, oxidation, box creases, tears or yellowing, and any repairs or modifications.
- The box and paperwork. Whether the original box, display base, certificate of authenticity and paperwork are included.
- Factory finishes. Intentional weathering on "dirty" or race-worn NASCAR finishes is called out, so it isn't mistaken for damage.
Model kits
Every kit listing states its build state plainly: factory sealed, unbuilt (open box), started (parts off the sprue, glue or paint applied) or built. A started or built kit is never graded Mint, however clean it looks. For unbuilt kits we check that the parts appear complete and on the sprue, and note the condition of the decal sheet and instructions.
Model trains
Powered trains are listed as tested or untested. We only say an item runs if we've tested it; anything else is sold untested, as is. Listings also note couplers, wheels and trucks, missing detail parts and whether the original box is included.
New or used?
Only factory-sealed items are sold as new. Anything opened or displayed is sold as used, even when it grades Mint, and the grade tells you how it actually looks.
Not sure about something?
Ask before you buy: email sales@castlediecast.com or text 904-497-0664 and we'll send more photos or check a detail for you. If an item doesn't match its description, see our refund policy.